| Platinum | Beefaroo |
| Gold | Johnny Pamcakes |
| Silver | Mary's Market Cafe & Bakery |
| Bronze | Backyard Grill & Bar |
| Top Pick | 8th Ward Pub |
| Top Pick | Alpine View Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Baker Street Burgers |
| Top Pick | chick-fil-a |
| Top Pick | Jessica's Restaurant Roscoe |
| Top Pick | Magpie |