| Platinum | Shine |
| Gold | Candle Crest Soy Candles |
| Silver | One Love Candle |
| Bronze | Wolf Hollow |
| Top Pick | Barnes & Noble Booksellers |
| Top Pick | Finials Scandinavian Gifts |
| Top Pick | Forever Blooms |
| Top Pick | Love of Life Creations, LLC |
| Top Pick | Spencer's |
| Top Pick | Village Green Home & Garden |