| Platinum | Pizza Ranch |
| Gold | Golden Chopsticks Buffet |
| Silver | Golden Corral Restaurants |
| Bronze | HomeTown Buffet |
| Top Pick | Cimino's Ristorante & Pizza |
| Top Pick | City Buffet |
| Top Pick | Seasoned With Shay, LLC |
| Top Pick | Spring Garden Family Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Stockholm Inn |