| Platinum | Lino's |
| Gold | Plume |
| Silver | Nunzio's Restaurant |
| Bronze | Salamone's Cherry Valley |
| Top Pick | Anna's Pizza |
| Top Pick | Bravo Pizza in South Beloit |
| Top Pick | Joe's Casa di Amici |
| Top Pick | Olive Garden Italian Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Salamone's North |
| Top Pick | Schiro's Restaurant & Lounge |