| Platinum | Pinnon Meats |
| Gold | Countryside Meats & Deli |
| Silver | Main Street Meat Co. |
| Bronze | Cattle and Cream |
| Top Pick | 640 Meats |
| Top Pick | Brian's Trade Rite Foods |
| Top Pick | Eichman's |
| Top Pick | Prairie Hill Meats |
| Top Pick | Van Laars Farm Market & Bake Shop |
| Top Pick | Woodman's Market |