| Platinum | Lino's |
| Gold | John's Restaurant & Pizzeria |
| Silver | Capri |
| Bronze | Pino's on Main Pizza |
| Top Pick | Carlyle Brewing Co. |
| Top Pick | Gerry's Pizza |
| Top Pick | Giuseppi's Pizzeria & Italian Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Maciano's Pizza & Pastaria |
| Top Pick | Salamone's Cherry Valley |
| Top Pick | Woodfire Brick Oven Pizza |