| Platinum | Secondhand Curves |
| Gold | Meme's Upscale Consignment |
| Silver | Carpenter's Corner |
| Bronze | The Pickin Chicks |
| Top Pick | Goodwill Industries of Northern Illinois |
| Top Pick | Hush Antiques Vintage |
| Top Pick | Rockford Rescue Mission |
| Top Pick | Seek & Find Consignment |
| Top Pick | Truly Treasured Gift N Thrift |
| Top Pick | Winnie Nutter Vintage |